The Concept of “Prophetic” Socialism by Max Scheler

The article analyzes the conceptual foundations of “prophetic” socialism by Max Scheler (1874–1928). The main principles of a new political and ideological doctrine at that time, designed to become, according to the plan of its creator, an “antidote” to Marxism, are considered. The author analyzes Scheler's argumentation, directed, on the one hand, against socialism in the Marxist interpretation, and on the other, at proving the legitimacy of using the terms “Christian socialism” and “Christian prophetic socialism”. Scheler opposes socialism, first of all, to individualism, which he interprets in social and moral-philosophical senses, and only secondarily to liberalism and capitalism. Socialism and individualism, which now appear as antagonistic tendencies of sociocultural development, are for him two equally necessary and interrelated essential principles of the social being of a person, understood as a spiritual-bodily social being. Individualistic tendencies, according to Scheler, prevailed over socialist tendencies in the West in modern times, therefore socialism in its Marxist interpretation turned out to be so in demand in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. But the destruction of private property is contrary to Christianity. “Forced communism” does not bring with it heaven on earth, but catastrophe and cultural degradation, he foreshadows. Based on the teachings of the Church Fathers and starting from the Catholic social doctrine, Scheler offers his vision of an ideal society in the form of a “personal community” (Personengemeinschaft), corresponding to the true destiny of a person. In it, the individual and social principles are in harmony and interdependent development. Scheler opposes the “prophetic” method of comprehending socio-historical reality, applied proceeding from the Christian solidarism ideal, to the materialistic understanding of history. He points to three advantages of his methodology: it takes into account human freedom, the uniqueness of a historical event, combines all types and methods of human cognition, without absolutizing the scientific form of knowledge. The author reveals the deep content of Scheler's definition of Marxism as “the protest ideology of oppressed classes”, drawing on the analysis of the “sociological doctrine of idols” of the late Scheler. In it, he reveals the pre-reflexive prerequisites for the formation of class ideologies. The author points to the essential kinship of the class prejudices about which the German philosopher wrote, and the national-mental prejudices of the political elites of the leading Western countries. In conclusion, he raises the question of how relevant the problems raised in Scheler's article are today in the context of modern Russian realities.

1. Scheler, M. (2020), Mysli o politike i morali [Thoughts on Politics and Morals], Transl. by Malinkin, A.N., Moscow, MSL, RUS.

2. Scheler, M. (1986), “Prophetischer oder marxistischer Sozialismus?”, Max Scheler. Gesammelte Werke. Bd. 6: Schriften zur Soziologie und Weltanschauungslehre, 3. durchges. Aufl., Hrsg. von Manfred

3. S. Frings, Bouvier Verlag, Herbert Grundmann, Bonn, GER, S. 259–272.

4. Sheler, M. (1999), Resentiment v strukture moraley [Ressentiment in the structure of morals], Transl. by Malinkin, A.N., Nauka, Universitetskaya kniga, SPb., RUS.

5. Scheler, M. (1980), “Der Formalismus in der Ethik und die materiale Wertethik. Neuer Versuch der Grundlegung eines ethischen Personalismus”, Max Scheler. Gesammelte Werke. Bd. 2, 6. durchges. Aufl., Hrsg. von Manfred S. Frings,Bern und München, Francke Verlag, GER.

6. Scheler, M. (2020), “Problems of religion. Towards a Religious Renewal”, O sushchnosti filosofii. Raboty raznykh let On the Essence of Philosophy. Works of different years, Transl. by Malinkin, A.N., Tsentr gumanitarnykh initsiativ, Moscow, SPb., RUS, pp. 118–165.

7. Scheler, M. (1982), “Christlicher Sozialismus als Antikapitalismus”, Max Scheler. Gesammelte Werke. Bd. 4: Politisch-pädagogische Schriften, Hrsg. von Manfred S. Frings, Francke Verlag, Bern und München, GER, S. 615–675.

8. Malinkin, A.N. (2019), Kontseptsiya fenomenologii Maksa Shelera. Sheler v Gusserl [Max Scheler's concept of phenomenology. Scheler v Husserl], Russkaya shkola, Moscow, RUS.

9. Scheler, M. (2011), “Sociology of knowledge and the theory of knowledge. Additions from the handwritten heritage to “Problems of the Sociology of Knowledge”, Problemy sotsiologii znaniya Problems of the Sociology of Knowledge, Transl. by Malinkin, A.N., Institut obshchegumanitarnykh issledovanii, Мoscow, RUS, pp. 215–218.

10. Scheler, M. (1994), “Man in the era of equalization”, Izbrannye proizvedeniya Selected Works, Transl. by Denezhkin, A.V., Malinkin, A.N. and Filippov, A.F., Gnosis, Moscow, RUS, pp. 98–128.

11. Malinkin, A.N. (2020), “Sociology and Philosophy: Inseparable and Non-Merged. The Birth of Marxist Sociology from the Spirit of Bolshevism. Part 1”, Sociological J., 2020, vol. 26, no. 3, pp. 148–171. DOI: 10.19181/socjour.2020.26.3.7399.

12. Malinkin, A.N. (2020), “Sociology and Philosophy: Inseparable and Non-merged. The Birth of Marxist Sociology from the Spirit of Bolshevism. Part 2”, Sociological J., 2020, vol. 26, no. 4, pp. 137–169. DOI: 10.19181/socjour.2020.26.4.7647.

13. Scheler, M. (1982), “Der Genius des Krieges und der Deutsche Krieg”, Max Scheler. Gesammelte Werke. Bd. 4: Politisch-pädagogische Schriften. Hrsg. von Manfred S. Frings, Francke Verlag, Bern und München, GER, S. 7–217.

14. Malinkin, A.N. (2020), “German-Russian historical parallels in the light of political philosophy and journalism of M. Scheler”, Sheler M. Mysli o politike i morali Scheler M. Thoughts on Politics and Morals, Transl. by Malinkin, A.N., Moscow, MSL, 2020. pp. 79–131.

15. Scheler, M. (1986), “Von zwei deutschen Krankheiten”, Max Scheler. Gesammelte Werke. Bd. 6: Schriften zur Soziologie und Weltanschauungslehre, 3. durchges. Aufl., Hrsg. von Manfred S. Frings, Bouvier Verlag, Herbert Grundmann, Bonn, GER, ss. 204–219.

16. Scheler, M. (2011), Problemy sotsiologii znaniya [Problems of the Sociology of Knowledge], Transl. by Malinkin, A.N., Institut obshchegumanitarnykh issledovanii, Мoscow, RUS.

17. Bukharin, N.I. (2008), “Philosophical Arabesques”, Uznik Lubyanki. Tyuremnye rukopisi Nikolaya Bukharina A Prisoner of the Lubyanka. Prison Manuscripts of Nikolai Bukharin, Moscow, AIRO-XXI, pp. 240–673.

18. Scheler, M. (1972), “Die Idole der Selbsterkenntnis”, Max Scheler. Gesammelte Werke. Bd. 3: Vom Umsturz der Werte. Abhandlungen und Aufsätze, 5. Aufl., Hrsg. von Maria Scheler, Francke Verlag, Bern und München, GER, S. 213–292.

19. Scheler, M. (1982), “Zur Psychologie des englischen Ethos und des Cant. Anhang zu: Der Genius des Krieges und der Deutsche Krieg“, Max Scheler. Gesammelte Werke. Bd. 4: Politisch-pädagogische Schriften, Hrsg. von Manfred S. Frings, Francke Verlag, Bern und München, GER, S. 218–250.

20. Soloviev, Vl.S. (2012), Opravdanie dobra. Nravstvennaya filosofiya Justifying Good. Moral philosophy], in Platonov, O.A. (ed.), Institut russkoi tsivilizatsii; Algoritm, Moscow, RUS.

21.